Related by context. All words. (Click for frequent words.) 81 mitigating circumstances 72 aggravating factors 67 mitigating factor 62 aggravating circumstances 62 aggravators 59 extenuating circumstances 59 mitigating circumstance 56 aggravating factor 54 extenuating factors 53 Aggravating factors 51 sentencer 50 statutory aggravators 49 factors 49 substantively unreasonable 49 reasonable factfinder 49 substantive reasonableness 48 Presentence Report 48 manifestly excessive 48 moral blameworthiness 48 reversible error 47 Mitigating factors 47 aggravator 47 probative value 47 mitigators 47 presentence report 46 moral culpability 46 genuine remorse 46 Appellant contends 46 Lord Pentland 45 instruct jurors 45 genuinely remorseful 45 sentencing guideline 45 postrelease control 44 heinous atrocious 44 especially heinous atrocious 44 Lord Carloway 44 reasonable trier 44 impose custodial sentence 44 aggravating circumstance 44 Justice Lasry 44 Lady Dorrian 44 Justice Panckhurst 44 uncharged offenses 44 Justice Gendall 44 disciplinary infractions 44 Judge Gless 44 presentence 44 evidentiary rulings 44 uncharged misconduct 44 Sentencing Guideline 44 procedural reasonableness 44 Justice Randerson 44 substantive unreasonableness 44 blameworthiness 44 Judge Finnane 44 procedurally unreasonable 43 custodial sentence 43 immediate custodial sentence 43 evidence adduced 43 unduly prejudicial 43 factual sufficiency 43 knowingly intelligently 43 uncontradicted testimony 43 curative instruction 43 Justice Whealy 43 Sheriff Foulis 43 leniency 43 DaRoyce 43 Judge Botting 43 Justice Sulan 43 Lord Brailsford 43 credibility determinations 43 Andrew Woolman 43 premeditation 43 nonfrivolous 43 involuntary intoxication 42 sentencing guidelines 42 § #K#.# 42 Mary Lou Rup 42 Judge Bisphan 42 Lidums 42 mitigating 42 Judge Eleri Rees 42 Lord Kinclaven 42 Rossanese 42 reweigh 42 § #A#.# 42 Joanne Eley 42 Justice Suzanne Bensler 42 inferences therefrom 42 plea colloquy 42 Rompilla 42 mitigatory 42 Judge Reddihough 42 parole eligibility 42 USSG § #B#.# [001] 42 unanimity instruction 42 ALJ erred 42 sua sponte duty 42 Solovan 42 Parnes contends 41 sincere remorse 41 Colin Charteris 41 extenuating 41 postconviction 41 Brian Collis QC 41 Judge Tony Adeane 41 resentence 41 Balfour Der 41 dispositional departure 41 determinate sentence 41 extrinsic evidence 41 Judge Gareth Hawkesworth 41 Suntag 41 Kopcow 41 Judge Benotto 41 factual determinations 41 jurors 41 convict Spector 41 reprehensibility 41 probabilities 41 Justice Warwick Gendall 41 reasonably arguable 41 Judge Punshon 41 Paul Holdenson QC 41 Dan Cordey 41 Mr Holdenson 41 variables 41 Nigel Soppitt 41 heinousness 41 unfairly prejudicial 41 sentences meted 41 habeas proceedings 41 postrelease supervision 41 Broccoletti 41 USSG § #E#.# 40 Judge Granville Styler 40 v. Heckler 40 Mr Justice Flaux 40 arguable merit 40 testifies truthfully 40 Lord Uist 40 remorse 40 counsel performed deficiently 40 conclusory assertion 40 CALJIC No. #.# 40 deeply remorseful 40 Judge Beverley Lunt 40 mental infirmity 40 IJ adverse 40 unrebutted testimony 40 Judge Roland Steinle 40 untimeliness 40 Prasertphong 40 confounding factors 40 adjudicating guilt 40 Gladsen 40 Judge Raoul Neave 40 Passing sentence 40 Extenuating circumstances 40 court procedurally erred 40 predicate acts 40 § #B#.# [001] 40 Presentence Investigation Report 40 Defence barrister 40 demonstrably unfit 40 Judge Bidois 40 juvenile adjudications 40 DelBigio 40 § #G#.# 40 presentencing investigation 40 punishments 40 Jazgar 40 inadmissible hearsay 40 Ibid. 40 Shepack 40 Justice Alexander Sosna 40 mere scintilla 40 Justice Sterling Sanderman 40 pro se litigant 40 judge Vladimir Usov 40 Judge Gittos 40 Saranchak 40 Judge Jonathan Geake 40 factfinder 40 sentence 40 presentencing report 40 sentencing 40 reweighing 40 ALJ 40 Judge Lord Bracadale 40 withhold adjudication 40 Lord Hardie 40 egregiousness 40 culpability 40 Judge Erber 40 Emmett Dunne 40 predicate offenses 40 Sheriff Lindsay Foulis 40 unduly prejudiced 40 John Reddihough 40 instruct sua sponte 40 reoffense 39 Sheriff Andrew Cubie 39 interrupted Wilbert 39 Judge Zohrab 39 posttrial motions 39 plainly erred 39 Delehey 39 Judge Doogue 39 Paul Batty QC 39 Attorney Shurland 39 Justice Goundar 39 Judge Larry Smukler 39 lenient sentence 39 hearsay objection 39 Mr Bellanto 39 Magistrate Bruce Schemioneck 39 Justice Venning 39 Judge Philip Wassall 39 procedural unconscionability 39 IJ erred 39 Frederick Bragdon 39 reasonable inferences 39 forensic psychiatrists 39 Rhys Rowlands 39 heinous cruel 39 Defendant asserts 39 Fla. 2d DCA 39 punishment 39 Matwiejczyk 39 manifestly inadequate 39 Roger Laybourn 39 Spreigl evidence 39 Judge Katherine Delahunt 39 Mr Rabbidge 39 attorney Jeff Jazgar 39 undue prejudice 39 Judge Chettle 39 § #L#.# 39 circumstancial evidence 39 Petitioner contends 39 Justice Nazhat Shameem 39 erroneous evidentiary rulings 39 Mellaci 39 presentence investigation 39 Justice Shan Tennent 39 hysteria attendant 39 Lord Bracadale 39 Judge Louis Bidois 39 alibi witnesses 39 Nanette Warner 39 attorney Andrew LoTempio 39 Dunphy Farris 39 unduly depreciate 39 DeVesa 39 attorney Rhoda Ricciardi 39 e vidence 39 Justice Baragwanath 39 factually distinguishable 39 USSG § 39 Neil McKittrick 39 uncharged crimes 39 contributory factors 39 attorney Brick Storts 39 foreseeability 39 concurrent sentences 39 Jonathan Teare 39 Scotillo 39 Gribble insanity 39 SSOSA 39 corpus delicti rule 39 readily provable 39 presumptively prejudicial 39 Daniel J. Gotlin 39 lengthy custodial sentence 39 sentencers 39 unduly lenient 39 Hedric 39 circumstantial evidence linking 39 Sarcione 39 gross disproportionality 39 Glenn Kelt 38 prejudice prong 38 Ms Popovic 38 unmeasured confounding 38 defendant 38 parole ineligibility 38 #B#.# 38 Dutcher slaying 38 Judge Coolahan 38 modified categorical 38 Merryday 38 Mr MacLynn 38 Stephen Gullick 38 evidentiary objections 38 § #E#.# 38 Katherine Delahunt 38 USSG § #G#.# 38 mistrials exclusion 38 largely circumstantial 38 Judge MacBride 38 Nastoff 38 psychosexual evaluation 38 Prosecutor Courtland Geyer 38 depraved manner 38 procedurally defaulted 38 BIA erred 38 Judge Sawako Gardner 38 Judge Pamela Badley 38 procedural flaws 38 D' Elia's cooperation 38 inculpatory statements 38 sincerely remorseful 38 lawyer Rebecca Snukal 38 summarily affirm 38 Mike Antunovic 38 Mr Saines 38 Kutmus 38 Sterling Sanderman 38 Justice McCombe 38 Magistrate Ron Saines 38 Federal Sentencing Guidelines 38 remorsefulness 38 Judge Krichbaum 38 Rick Saull 38 Sueyres 38 Judge Soulio 38 NJSA 2C :# 1a 38 dissimilarities 38 Mr Justice Leveson 38 § #K#.# b 38 jury 38 Mitigating 38 Sanzar judicial officer 38 Dallet 38 voluntariness 38 Armengau 38 presiding magistrate 38 Fletcher Pilditch 38 detriments 38 Gnoss 38 E vidence 38 Appellant argues 38 argument unpersuasive 38 Tennard 38 Justice Peter Blaxell 38 Bridget Mackintosh 38 Appellants argue 38 manifest injustice 38 Judge Oke Blaikie 38 Reinholtsen 38 circum stances 38 attorney Alan Zwirblis 38 noncapital 38 Mary Ellen Attridge 38 Aggravating circumstances 38 uncharged misconduct evidence 38 probationary sentence 38 Allendoerfer 38 uncontradicted 38 parol evidence 38 attorney Len Kachinsky 38 Judge Peter Testar 38 habeas proceeding 38 rational trier 38 Judge Desmond Marrinan 38 Judge Margaret Rizkalla 38 Pockele 38 prima facie case 38 c ounsel 38 uncontradicted evidence 38 sua sponte 38 substantively reasonable 38 proximate causation 38 particularized facts 38 Mr Boulten 38 purely circumstantial 38 Lord Nimmo 38 evidence 38 article defamed Fawcett 38 Defendant argues 38 affiants 38 Justice Openshaw 38 linking Guandique 38 WCJ 38 Hrvol 38 irreparable misidentification 38 Midanik 38 lawyer Maurice Sercarz 37 non compliances 37 Salvador Rosas 37 Magistrate Maurice Gurvich 37 Lasnik 37 Prosecuting counsel 37 wrongfulness 37 Justice Bruce Durno 37 Judge Wassall 37 Marnocha 37 presumptively reasonable 37 Roozrokh administered 37 grossly disproportional 37 Georgia Cappleman 37 JNOV motion 37 offenses 37 Judge Josephine Bouchier 37 remorseful 37 Compensatory damages 37 James Broccoletti 37 Faretta motion 37 Judge Adeane 37 De la Rionda 37 Commission SCCRC 37 CrR #.# 37 inconsistencies 37 adverse inference 37 Preleski 37 reasonable inferences therefrom 37 Judge Anthony Whealy 37 insufficient evidence 37 Judge Wodak 37 Judge Chivell 37 ordered presentence investigation 37 Judge Christopher Elwen 37 unmeasured factors 37 postconviction proceedings 37 reasonable inferences drawn 37 Lympus 37 Christopher Critchlow 37 hearsay testimony 37 arguments 37 Marschewski 37 confounding variables 37 Lord Mance 37 UCBR 37 Hawai'i Paroling Authority 37 resentencings 37 Judge Marcelo Kopcow 37 Osowik 37 Mr Sofronoff 37 allocution 37 Mr Lerve 37 pharmacological interventions 37 Judge Kenn Bellerose 37 Sanderman 37 recidivist offender 37 non custodial sentences 37 contributory negligence 37 Rusty Akins 37 Abdur'Rahman 37 prosecutors retrying Blagojevich 37 Dalmyn 37 Crown prosecutor 37 Stephen Sillman 37 Presiding magistrate 37 Hofsheier 37 sat emotionless 37 corpus delicti 37 withheld adjudication 37 habitual offender enhancement 37 punishement 37 lawyer Alain Hepner 37 Lord Woolman 37 Evidence Code 37 Bertani Tomczak 37 Bakalis 37 Petitioner argues 37 juror misconduct 37 borderline retarded 37 § #B#.# [002] 37 affirmative defenses 37 Lord Macphail 37 nolo contendere plea 37 w hether 37 procedural irregularity 37 trier 37 Broscius 37 attorney Howard Ehring 37 draw reasonable inferences 37 Robert Altice 37 adjudicated delinquent 37 Justice Timothy Studdert 37 Basson acquittal 37 circumstantial evidence 37 Lord Bannatyne 37 triable 37 requested continuance 37 John Kastrenakes 37 attorney Steven Freers 37 pretrial motions 37 Judge Dirk Sandefur 37 Paul Mabey QC 37 attenuating circumstances 37 Synenberg 37 Abe Motala 37 Skoropada 37 Acting Deemster 37 manifestly unjust 37 plea allocution 37 non insane automatism 37 Zonay 37 v. Apfel 37 methodological flaws 37 mildly mentally retarded 37 Sheriff Rajni Swanney 37 David Brustman SC 37 limine motions 37 contemporaneous objection 37 James Sturman QC 37 Justice Ian Nordheimer 37 Jonathan Karesh 37 Tollerud committee 37 lawyer Christopher Plourd 37 heinous atrocity 37 bindover 37 William Rollstin 37 Judge Mosby Perrow 37 Judge Nordheimer 37 nonfrivolous issue 37 Lord Kingarth 37 attorney Jeffrey Jakmides 36 Lisnek 36 nonviolent offender 36 mens rea 36 lawyer Cesar Nakazaki 36 probative 36 disadvantages 36 Sentencing Guidelines Manual 36 David Suntag 36 Alan Gless 36 Alford Doctrine meaning 36 Lord Emslie 36 Justice Salesi Temo 36 Donalty 36 insane automatism 36 Justice Anthe Philippides 36 considerations 36 Justice Hoeben 36 Allan J. Preckel 36 Marianne Battani 36 factually innocent 36 inconsistences 36 Negangard argued 36 Judge Tony Zohrab 36 Nicarico murder 36 c ourt 36 Lamiero 36 judge Lord Bracadale 36 Gedansky 36 mistrial motions 36 Yousuf Hammad 36 Code § #-#.# 36 Mark Zarifeh 36 Intervenors 36 impaneling jury 36 Judge Gullaci 36 Jeff Zimel 36 Mr Katonivualiku 36 continuances 36 Prosecutor Vince Imbordino 36 accomplice Joshua Komisarjevsky 36 Judge Felicity Hampel 36 ordered presentencing 36 Magistrate Giovanni Grixti 36 maximum sentence 36 attorney Douglas Horngrad 36 Judge Bosielo 36 unremorseful 36 Amble testified 36 adverse inferences 36 Scott Drabenstadt 36 Timothy Clayson 36 adduce evidence 36 Lawrence Antolini 36 lawyer Brian Legghio 36 Steven Mottinger 36 postconviction petition 36 Judge Andrew Nastoff 36 borderline personality disorder 36 surrebuttal 36 #K#.# 36 JNOV 36 Bonginkosi Sigenu 36 Assuming arguendo 36 SANZAR Judicial Officer 36 appellant contentions 36 Jarrett Ferentino 36 Joyce Dalmyn 36 Ron Piche 36 girlfriend Amber Meidinger 36 harsher sentence 36 manifestly unreasonable 36 habeas relief 36 n.5 36 Consuelo Scerri Herrera 36 Magistrate Khamisi Tokunbo 36 lawyer Peter Brauti 36 Assistant Appellate Defender 36 contentions 36 Ms Milledge 36 Studstrup 36 Winston Terracini SC 36 USSG § #D#.# 36 Magistrate Saviour Demicoli 36 State ex rel 36 reasons 36 Fred Hardt 36 Ahto 36 Judge Lord Kinclaven 36 Waidla 36 Plea bargains 36 Evid. Code § 36 acute stress disorder 36 Cepparulo 36 Judge Alistair McCreath 36 Preckel 36 Justice Roderick Howie 36 Kevin Lennen 36 posttrial 36 uncontroverted facts 36 voire dire 36 defender Howard Ehring 36 legitimate penological interests 36 lenient sentences 36 misbehaviours 36 constitutionally deficient 36 Francisco Briseno 36 Justice Peter Dutney 36 Prosecutor Joyce Dalmyn 36 Brendan Grehan 36 Eddie Callagain 36 taped confession 36 Justice Studdert 36 Judy Clendenning 36 convictions 36 confounders 36 La.Civ.Code art 36 Pasell 36 custodial sentences 36 Songy Turner 36 Liell 36 acted immaturely 36 gentlemanly wagers 36 Mollway 36 psychologist Kirk Heilbrun 36 Punitive damages penalize 36 internalizing behaviors 36 Michael Pert QC 36 resentencing 36 recklessly indifferent 36 Sheriff Noel McPartlin 36 Judge Barbara Ansted 36 Ben Massar Finley 36 criminally responsible 36 uncontroverted evidence 36 Opening Br 36 Howard Goldkind 36 Tom Prasertphong 36 Prosecutor Chris Lamiero 36 Judge Adrian Fulford 36 Justice Graham Panckhurst 36 permissibly 36 excusable homicide 36 testimonial hearsay 36 evident partiality 36 Sentencing Resident Magistrate 36 noncapital cases 36 Judith Ablett 36 inculpatory evidence 36 CALCRIM 36 Polygraph examinations 36 implied malice 36 Sharon Prather 36 Gord Haight 36 Mangerson 36 attorney Alan Fanter 36 Sentencing Guidelines 36 plausible explanations 36 legitimate penological 36 Sheriff Douglas Cusine 36 liberally construe 36 overborne 36 attorney Myron Auerbach 36 circumstantial 36 Acting Judge Ndita 36 Swanum 36 Gripon 36 attorney Fred Duchardt 36 Justice Blaxell 35 Puisne Judge Carlisle 35 Jonathan Hak 35 mental incompetency 35 Huerstel 35 Hughes Bygott 35 nonjurisdictional 35 withholding potentially exculpatory 35 Fetky 35 testifying truthfully 35 declaring mistrial 35 John Milmo QC 35 § #C#.# 35 Brinkema barred 35 attorney Vicki Podberesky 35 RCr #.# 35 Justice Raynor Asher 35 Werdegar wrote 35 v. Astrue 35 Thomas Felnagle 35 RADB 35 priors 35 Eighth Amendment forbids 35 reasonable chastisement 35 § #B#.# b 35 Justice Lex Lasry 35 Stuart M. Schimelman 35 Maybrown 35 Judge Andrew Gilbart 35 Judge Davinder Lachlar 35 CALCRIM No. 35 indeterminate sentences 35 equitable estoppel 35 Hilow 35 Pilshaw 35 mens rea element 35 John Kavanewsky Jr. 35 attorney Adam Tebrugge 35 Benotto 35 Etta Simmons 35 § #D#.# 35 Judge Hawkesworth 35 #/#-year sentence [003] 35 Stacy Uliana 35 People v. Gardeley 35 Terrence Boren 35 Craig Hedric 35 Wymard 35 Judge D' Apolito 35 Sweazea 35 Strattard 35 misapprehended 35 lawyer Frank Mondano 35 John E. Blahovec 35 objectively unreasonable 35 codefendant 35 Judge Thomas Zonay 35 youthful offender 35 Smyrnes Knight 35 methodological limitations 35 Yusuf Abdillh Jamma 35 Justice Shameem 35 appellant 35 indictable offenses 35 nonappealable 35 mitigants 35 Judge Simandle 35 Joseph Remiro 35 Davick Halfen 35 inferences 35 recusal motion 35 USSG § #C#.# 35 Mr Klestadt 35 reoffender 35 Legghio 35 Justice Pierre Slicer 35 Mr Bhila 35 Marcelain 35 Judge Elna Revelas 35 Bucklo 35 LERB 35 sentences consecutively 35 plea bargains 35 Justice Siopis 35 plea bargained 35 sexually deviant behavior 35 Internal quotation marks 35 Almendarez Torres 35 RFU disciplinary officer 35 forcible felonies 35 disclose exculpatory evidence 35 justifiable inferences 35 dicta 35 Judge Merfyn Hughes 35 prejudicial 35 Brian Heberlig 35 unduly lenient sentence 35 Domalakes 35 attorney Brandie Devall 35 inapposite 35 officer Dennis Wheelahan 35 v. Quarterman 35 Judge Michael Mettyear 35 Brent Stanaway 35 Justice Rommel Masse 35 Magistrate Dan Muling 35 controverting evidence 35 postconviction motion 35 Justice Gregory Carro 35 section #.#.# 35 conflicting inferences 35 Justice Anthony Whealy 35 Judith McDonald Burkman 35 Claire Boshier 35 extenuating circumstance 35 Judge Lord Uist 35 subparts 35 probated sentence 35 mitigation 35 D efendant 35 Gabeljic 35 Justice Toulson 35 Dearington 35 court prejudicially erred 35 Dr. Shabehram Lohrasbe 35 Taeotui 35 unduly harsh 35 redeeming qualities 35 substantive unconscionability 35 Pissetzky 35 sentences concurrently 35 Fiona Bagnall 35 Nebush 35 contempts 35 Separate juries 35 Rashade 35 rea sons 35 prosecutor Len Doust 35 judge Lord Kinclaven 35 Ferencek 35 Isaac Borenstein 35 sentences 35 claimant RFC 35 Apprendi 35 probation revocations 35 prime facie 35 eyewitness identifications 35 Johnnie Mask 35 juror questionnaire 35 Respondent concedes 35 realizability 35 nonfrivolous issues 35 Justice Penry Davey 35 attorney Birney Bervar 35 v Goord 35 Judge Manck 35 Mutilating corpse carries 35 lodestar calculation 35 expressed remorse 35 issue preclusion 35 nonmovant 35 Stephan Schick 35 undergo psychosexual evaluation 35 Wilzbach 35 Jane Farish 35 Jane Campton 35 unsampled intervals 35 appellees 35 Dexter Del Rosario 35 Michael Morchower 35 Tom Gillert 35 Premeditated murder carries 35 d efendant 35 Magistrate Jelena Popovic 35 felony convictions 35 pardon forgave 35 Judge Chiman Patel 35 Baylson 35 Hope Seeley 35 #.# subd [002] 35 uncontroverted testimony 35 factual underpinnings 35 statutorily enumerated 35 Harry Dest 35 Graham Cottle 35 Puisne Judge Charles 35 Sadoff testimony 35 Eighth Amendment prohibits 35 Defending barrister 35 Nordheimer 35 bifurcated proceeding 35 Timothy Casserly 35 Cebull 35 Diane Druzinski 35 Zanethemba Gwada 35 pronounced DOIK 35 El Cajon Superior Court 35 raise triable 35 Judge Devins 35 Andrew Oldland 35 Justice Geoffrey Venning 35 rebuttable presumption 35 Noneconomic damages 35 Involuntary manslaughter 35 Judge Thomas Marcelain 35 Ben Yisrayl 35 wholly circumstantial 35 Sultan Hashim al 35 Gary Gotlieb 35 Justice Daniel Goundar 35 Judge Runston Maino 35 evidential basis 35 Judge Joop Labuschagne 35 Gregg Lerman 35 additur 34 recantations 34 Taufahema 34 Roeder stalked 34 Judge Bernard Hampsey 34 Judge Cynthia Imperato 34 factual inferences 34 Ex Post Facto 34 Judge Bruce Romanick 34 Judge Scott Drazewski 34 George Bakalis 34 H. Dohn 34 attorney Barry Beroset 34 Cliff Cretan 34 Jeremy Dein 34 Edward Batzig Jr. 34 separate concurring opinion 34 Steve Schroering 34 Simon Medland 34 Vince Rabil 34 mental abnormality 34 attorney Anne Beles 34 State Farm Mut 34 Frikkie du Preez 34 Judge Esmond Faulks 34 Jeff Kalmakoff 34 Penifoti Taeotui 34 lv denied 34 prejudicial publicity 34 DeMolle 34 proportionality 34 Alcotest readings 34 Judge Murrough Connellan 34 Massameno 34 Magistrate Reg Marron 34 Joseph Claps 34 Nicholas Loraine 34 Prosecutor Rick Unklesbay 34 Judge Mpati 34 overbreadth 34 Margaret Nyland 34 Buntion 34 C ourt 34 precluded summary judgment 34 causative factors 34 nol pros 34 Michael Kupersmith 34 Justice Akenhead 34 Judge O Buachalla 34 Marthage 34 stressors 34 Leane Zainea 34 counsel Brendan Grehan 34 Jon Helland 34 Sigenu 34 Magistrate Peet 34 objectively verifiable 34 USSG § #A#.# 34 conclusory statements 34 Ms Syme 34 simulate flatulence 34 Christopher Droney 34 plea bargain 34 causal connection 34 NW2d 34 Grunander 34 Magistrates adjourned 34 Rimpa Haldhar 34 factual assertions 34 equitable tolling 34 Justice Ged Hawco 34 Mr Clisdell 34 F. App'x 34 spare Getsy 34 Ribitwer 34 lodestar method 34 voluntarily absented himself 34 Judge Deborah Bernini 34 Paul Belzil 34 Student Athlete Reinstatement 34 rearraignment 34 Andrew Haesler SC 34 RFU Disciplinary Officer 34 F. Fasel 34 Govendo 34 Druzinski 34 attorney Sam Shamansky 34 lawyer Jeffrey Steinback 34 legally cognizable 34 corroborative evidence 34 Belmontes 34 colorable claim 34 stabbing Kimberly Cates 34 Commissioner TC Memo 34 conclusory allegation 34 presentencing 34 Judge Geoffrey Chettle