Related by context. All words. (Click for frequent words.) 58 habeas proceeding 58 Younger abstention 56 habeas proceedings 56 adjudicative 56 factual determinations 55 factfinder 54 Rule #:#-# [002] 54 adjudicatory 54 quasi judicial proceeding 54 Pitchess discovery 54 appelate 54 quasi judicial proceedings 54 Defendant asserts 54 posttrial 54 mootness 54 C ourt 54 judicial estoppel 53 Appellant asserts 53 Petitioners contend 53 Appellants contend 53 jurisdictional prerequisite 53 sua sponte 53 Rooker Feldman doctrine 53 JNOV motion 53 conclusory statements 53 movants 53 Appellate Division affirmed 53 fraudulent joinder 53 lodestar method 53 arguable merit 53 controverting 52 La.Civ.Code art 52 adducing evidence 52 empanelling 52 contemporaneous objection 52 ore tenus 52 evidentiary rulings 52 e vidence 52 procedural reasonableness 52 reasonably arguable 52 curative instruction 52 inapplicability 52 quasijudicial 51 preclusive effect 51 Spreigl evidence 51 fi ndings 51 mere surplusage 51 § #C#.# 51 Petitioner argues 51 dispositive motion 51 postjudgment interest 51 coram nobis relief 51 prehearing 51 suspensive effect 51 quasi judicial powers 51 Ms Justice Laffoy 51 GL c 51 sua sponte duty 51 nonfrivolous 51 adjudicative functions 51 credibility determinations 51 writ petitioners 51 Board ASLB 51 quasi judicial immunity 51 adduce evidence 51 FSIA 51 p laintiff 51 habeas corpus proceeding 51 LHC Rawalpindi Bench 51 Justice Dotse 51 UCBR 50 parol evidence 50 SLUSA 50 substantive unreasonableness 50 purposeful availment 50 Faretta motion 50 habeas statute 50 deportability 50 determinations de novo 50 Rule #:#-# [001] 50 claim preclusion 50 Investigatory Committee 50 presumptively prejudicial 50 lodestar calculation 50 bsent 50 Justice Opene 50 postconviction petition 50 anti SLAPP motions 50 Respondent concedes 50 Respondent contends 50 Judge Yevgeny Zubov 50 summary affirmance 50 Appellants argue 50 Judicature Act 50 irrebuttable 50 issue preclusion 50 Pitchess motion 50 § #-#.# [002] 50 misapprehends 50 statutorily prescribed 50 Plaintiffs contend 50 factual sufficiency 50 grievant 50 c ourt 50 Justice Shuaibu 50 non justiciable 50 Criminal Procedural Code 50 posttrial motion 50 impugned judgment 50 procedural unconscionability 50 malafides 50 factual predicate 50 SCR #:#.# [001] 50 SL Bhayana 50 adjudication 50 redetermine 50 postconviction proceedings 50 appellate 49 minitrial 49 Appellant argues 49 5th DCA 49 habeas relief 49 Defendant contends 49 Eleventh Circuit affirmed 49 c ounsel 49 Justice Bhunu 49 parental unfitness 49 functus officio 49 P laintiff 49 CrR #.# 49 Justice Shameem 49 Faretta v. California 49 CPLR article 49 remittitur 49 Opening Br 49 inter partes 49 judge Emmet Sullivan 49 vacatur 49 assume arguendo 49 colorable claim 49 attained finality 49 reviewed de novo 49 postconviction counsel 49 procedural technicalities 49 exparte 49 Khalilur Rehman Ramday 49 SC collegium 49 Aruna Suresh 49 Judge Sprizzo 49 w henever 49 sua sponte dismissal 49 Mr. Miloševic 49 Ms Aikins 49 procedurally flawed 49 Credibility determinations 49 Penal Code Sec 49 Petitioner contends 49 extrinsic evidence 49 unliquidated damages 49 forum non conveniens 49 procedurally defective 49 uncharged misconduct evidence 49 habeas petitioner 49 mootness doctrine 49 voire dire 49 presumptively valid 49 Justice Abutu 49 Justice Chikere 49 nonmovant 49 uncharged misconduct 49 JLSC 49 arbitral proceedings 49 Ark. R. Civ 49 postconviction proceeding 49 BIA denial 49 Appellants assert 49 Competition Appellate Tribunal 49 La.Code Crim.P. art 49 plaintiffs appellants 49 habeas petitioners 49 justiciability 49 summary judgment de novo 49 arbitrability 48 reh'g 48 u nless 48 Justice Ojwang 48 appellants 48 Parliamentary Standing Orders 48 procedural irregularity 48 untimeliness 48 Rule XIX 48 Appellant contends 48 factually distinguishable 48 PP Bhatt 48 adjudicatory proceeding 48 Nkabinde J 48 Aplt 48 petitioner 48 prosecutorial impropriety 48 unsworn testimony 48 La.Code Civ.P. art 48 factual underpinnings 48 Munby J 48 Murtaza Bhutto murder 48 RCr #.# 48 CALCRIM Nos. 48 PERB 48 Dr Bulaya 48 Sir Thayne Forbes 48 Daniel Musinga 48 argument unpersuasive 48 Speedy Trial Act 48 n othing 48 Justice Ayebi 48 parol evidence rule 48 f ailure 48 court prejudicially erred 48 Ex Post Facto 48 hearsay objection 48 Election Tribunals 48 instruct sua sponte 48 Reinholtsen 48 Justice Duose 48 Sir Elihu Lauterpacht 48 section #.#b 48 contemporaneous documentation 48 Collateral estoppel 48 construing statutes 48 ex parte communication 48 Johnson v. Eisentrager 48 bindover 48 reversible error 48 Confrontation Clause 48 draw reasonable inferences 48 CFATF 48 Voir dire 48 equitable mootness 48 4th DCA 48 Meralco GSIS case 48 Wuaku Commission 48 equitable apportionment 48 presentence credits 48 nonjurisdictional 48 CAFC affirmed 48 exparte application 48 postconviction motion 48 rendered nugatory 48 Bibit Chandra 48 voir dire examination 48 justiciable controversy 47 Fla. 2d DCA 47 Usha Mehra 47 IJ erred 47 Declaratory Judgment Act 47 Justice Karwi 47 unanimity instruction 47 prima facia 47 Defendant argues 47 appellants contend 47 CrR 47 Judge Arthur Barcinas 47 judicial 47 NJPMC 47 Title VII retaliation 47 mem. op 47 preclude summary judgment 47 order sustaining demurrer 47 proximate causation 47 postjudgment 47 motu propio 47 Wis. Stat 47 § #-#-# [006] 47 substantive unconscionability 47 jurisdictional defect 47 ex mero motu 47 Mr. Narmont 47 Judge Lokuta 47 permissibly 47 Mr Nchito 47 magistrate Miriam Hayman 47 Appellate Panel 47 OCGA § #-#-# [007] 47 interlocutory appeals 47 judgment nunc pro 47 investigatory 47 Justice Garwe 47 procedural unfairness 47 standardless 47 collegiums 47 constitutionally deficient 47 #.# subdivision [004] 47 Criminal Procedure Law 47 Justice Babs Kuewumi 47 Iziyon 47 Philip Waki 47 evidentiary hearing 47 reinvestigations 47 GSIS Meralco 47 appellant 47 Minn. R. Civ 47 Justice Omerjee 47 Appellate Term 47 PCRA hearings 47 Judge Ekaterina Trendafilova 47 testimonial hearsay 47 Izinyon 47 Sandiganbayan justices 47 Fed.R.Civ.P. 47 Zuma Thint 47 reweigh 47 acted ultra vires 47 equitable tolling 47 P laintiffs 47 Evid. Code § 47 summarily affirm 47 clarificatory 47 egregious prosecutorial misconduct 47 relitigation 47 impermissibly 47 nonjusticiable 47 willfully obstructed 47 PRRB 47 NAB Ordinance 47 Justice Anwuri Chikere 47 Plaintiff Complaint 47 Mumbuna 47 manifestly unreliable 47 dism'd 47 Judge Anne Mactavish 47 contemnor 47 Manoj Narula 47 Justice Surya Kant 47 NJSA #:#-#.# [003] 47 adduce sufficient 47 Justice Ishaq Bello 47 Oyetibo 47 E vidence 47 condemnor 47 NRO verdict 47 § #-# [001] 46 reasonable inferences drawn 46 Benjamin Kubo 46 remanding 46 mala fides 46 reasonableness 46 Justice JH Bhatia 46 equitably tolled 46 Justice Tariq Parvez 46 Stephen Adah 46 Justice Victor Omage 46 peremptory writ 46 Originating Summons 46 OPCAT 46 Lord Glennie 46 Justice Manmohan Sarin 46 Basson acquittal 46 Moscow Basmanny 46 nontestimonial 46 Justice Okon Abang 46 u pon 46 Hofsheier 46 PAJA 46 adjudicating disputes 46 Bruselas 46 arbitral tribunal 46 impaneling jury 46 Mridula Bhatkar 46 Relators 46 Hlophe JP 46 judge OP Saini 46 Judgment affirmed 46 coram nobis 46 LSA RS #:# [002] 46 affidavits depositions 46 CAFA jurisdiction 46 nonobviousness 46 reargument 46 1st DCA 46 evidence adduced 46 Movants 46 Departmental Promotion Committee 46 deponent 46 unnecessary adjournments 46 overbreadth 46 § #-#-#.# 46 commssion 46 Enabling Clause 46 Muhammad Munir Paracha 46 habeas 46 UNCAT 46 Civil Procedure Code 46 liberally construe 46 sub silentio 46 Due Process Clause 46 DPP Chenge 46 Tenn. R. Civ 46 Claimant contends 46 arbitral tribunals 46 Justice Falak Sher 46 w hether 46 alleged contemnor 46 Justice Adebukola Banjoko 46 colorable 46 thecase 46 ITLOS 46 Elias Zacarias 46 uncontroverted testimony 46 Justice Festus Azangalala 46 Judge Monti Belot 46 En banc 46 Tax Injunction 46 #.# subdivision [002] 46 Skonier 46 § #-#-# [002] 46 SOAH 46 declaratory judgments 46 counsel performed deficiently 46 Justice Emukule 46 ICSID tribunal 46 International Arbitration LCIA 46 ICSID arbitration 46 excusal 46 prosecutor Satish Borulkar 46 CSRT panels 46 Judge Dan Abutu 46 pro se litigant 46 particularized facts 46 Justice Brobbey 46 ex parte application 46 Justice KN Saikia 46 lawyer Sharifuddin Pirzada 46 Code § #-#.# 46 spousal privilege 46 sub nom 46 BIA erred 46 Eleventh Circuits 46 constituted willful misconduct 46 PK Balasubramanyam 46 ICSID Convention 46 § #-#.# [004] 46 mens rea requirement 46 REMANDED 46 factual predicates 46 Judge Maraman 46 Judge Samuel Bosire 46 adjudicatory hearing 46 equitable subordination 46 Daryl Borgquist spokesman 46 excusable neglect 46 Ravelston Entities 46 mandamus proceeding 46 d efendant 46 reasonable factfinder 46 CALJIC No. #.# 46 Petitioner 46 Reply Brief 46 respectfully submits 46 Flast v. Cohen 46 Wyo. Stat 46 Commissioner Ridwan Ibrahim 46 plainly erroneous 46 Justices SB Sinha 46 constituting quorum 46 USSG § 46 Leonard Njagi 46 corpus delicti 46 Their Lordships 46 pendente lite 46 Presentence Report 46 NJRE 46 Justice Pathik 46 lenity 46 Dharmesh Sharma 46 lawyer Alessia Sorgato 46 procedurally defaulted 46 AM Thipsay 46 Edward Zacca 46 Omage 46 constitutionally delegated 46 quasi judicial body 46 statutorily authorized 46 Justice Jamadar 46 Eleventh Amendment 46 Ms. Dannehy 45 NRS #.# [003] 45 Plaintiff contends 45 substantive reasonableness 45 dispositional order 45 BPAI 45 Justice Shakirullah Jan 45 voluntariness 45 fact finder 45 Inquiry COI 45 expeditious disposal 45 dispositive motions 45 Justice Apondi 45 YAŞ 45 § 7A 45 controvert 45 procedurally barred 45 JJSO 45 interlocutory appeal 45 Evidence Code 45 POTA Review 45 mere scintilla 45 assuming arguendo 45 qui tam plaintiff 45 Dispute Settlement Body 45 mistake inadvertence surprise 45 Mohamad Zabidin 45 inter partes reexamination 45 CAFC reversed 45 court.The 45 cousel 45 Justice Farkye 45 unallotment statute 45 PPRA rules 45 Attorney Doron Weinberg 45 § #A#.# 45 impugned notification 45 Tibulya 45 Justice Jide Aladejana 45 legally cognizable 45 corpus delicti rule 45 triable 45 Judges Inquiry 45 Judge SK Sarvaria 45 Justice Isa Salami 45 precedential value 45 Solicitor Chrissy Adams 45 Code Civ 45 Justice Nyamu 45 manifestly unreasonable 45 Judge LT Simes 45 impermissible intrusion 45 Res judicata 45 Compl. ¶ 45 Judge Justice Nazhat 45 nonjury civil 45 ResQNet 45 CFR § #.# [005] 45 responsive pleadings 45 Tafas v. Doll 45 Rooker Feldman 45 Faretta 45 La. Code Civ 45 factual contentions 45 Justice Ogebe 45 propria persona 45 Magistrate Kafunda 45 AK Dogar 45 arbitrarily capriciously 45 quo warranto 45 Appellate Division reversed 45 surrebuttal 45 Justice Ibrahim Auta 45 spokesperson Midas Marquez 45 Judge Daniel Fransen 45 scrivener error 45 § #K#.# 45 neutral decisionmaker 45 s tate 45 Commission JLSC 45 Justice Maphalala 45 § #.# [003] 45 tunc 45 OCGA § #-#-# [004] 45 RK Saini 45 section #.#.# 45 Rossanese 45 blameworthiness 45 Judge Paddington Garwe 45 mandamus petition 45 Rev. Rul 45 Mrs Justice Abban 45 Ibiyeye 45 interlocutory judgment 45 ALJs 45 Dangerousness 45 Justice Wowo 45 Ibid. 45 precluded summary judgment 45 compensability 45 Markandeya Katju 45 judge Giancarlo Massei 45 uncontradicted testimony 45 severability 45 Anthony Scrivener QC 45 counsel RK Naseem 45 IAEA Statute 45 Justice Anin Yeboah 45 counsel YV Giri 45 Tribunal CSRT 45 Malimath 45 Justice Nasirul Mulk 45 constitutionally impermissible 45 Investigative Subcommittee 45 Adv Bizos 45 Justice Dinakaran elevation 45 PLRB 45 Section #.#.# [001] 45 Justice Javed Buttar 45 PCRA petition 45 Independent Electoral Commissions SIECs 45 Gopal Chaturvedi 45 nonfrivolous issue 45 ASLB 45 facially invalid 45 JUSTICE STEVENS 45 Justice Sirpurkar 45 JMOL 45 substantively unconscionable 45 Redesign Panel 45 Ramiz Rzayev 45 Justice Jeevan Reddy 45 Judge Luckern 45 Judge Abhay Thipsay 45 potentially exculpatory 45 Dr Khaminwa 45 Parliamentary Standing Committees 45 SN Dhingra 45 Justice retd. 45 LERB 45 rem jurisdiction 45 Saranchak 45 Justice Nawaz Abbasi 45 Klaus Tolksdorf 45 Double Jeopardy Clause 45 appellant contends 45 inferences therefrom 45 CJP remarked 45 arbitral 45 IJ adverse 45 xxxi adverse tax 45 petitioner prayed 45 USSG § #G#.# 45 § #-#-# [004] 45 Justice Mudgal 45 D efendant 45 Wilfred Nderitu 45 requestor petitioner 45 Joseph Nyamu 45 Subsection c 45 Justice Bamwine 45 pro hac vice 45 Magistrate Miriam Hayman 45 interlocutory orders 45 manifest disregard 45 IRCP 45 senior advocate Mukul 45 Rule #:#-# b 44 LHC registrar 44 Blakely v. 44 Uniform Rules 44 scienter requirement 44 Administrative Tribunals 44 purposefully availed itself 44 adjudicating guilt 44 McNicolls 44 suo motto cognizance 44 estop 44 Marc Nadon 44 SJ Kathawala 44 Roselyne Wendoh 44 t hese 44 Mr. Rotimi Jacobs 44 Emmanuel Fagbenle 44 remands 44 House Speaker Barendra 44 Criminal Prosecution Service 44 Appellate Courts 44 granting anticipatory bail 44 Appellant 44 nondischargeability 44 Eleventh Circuit 44 unreviewable 44 displinary 44 Third Amended Complaint 44 Maynard recused himself 44 Malimath Committee 44 Justice Abdul Kafarati 44 intendment 44 admiralty jurisdiction 44 prosection 44 Judge Preska 44 amicus curie 44 conclusions de novo 44 evidentiary 44 Justice Paradza 44 Justice Saka Ibiyeye 44 Superannuation Complaints 44 Presidential Election Petitions 44 statutory 44 Justice EK Ayebi 44 Judge Hans Liljeberg 44 nolo contendere plea 44 L.Ed. 2d 44 ripeness doctrine 44 Lago Agrio plaintiffs 44 justiciable 44 appellant asserts 44 Issue preclusion 44 WCJ 44 Section #B#.# 44 Arbitral Tribunal 44 JEOM 44 WCAB 44 Nagendra Rai 44 OCGA § #-#-#.# 44 Bilal Nazki 44 conclusory assertions 44 acquital 44 s uch 44 comprising Justices P Sathasivam 44 raise triable 44 Judge SM Shembole 44 Petitioner counsel 44 Appointments Clause 44 Disciplinary Committees 44 Mr Mutembei 44 § #A.# 44 Binalshibh interrogation 44 People v. Wende 44 compellable 44 reweighing 44 Flynt nephews 44 Enemy combatant 44 Mukundakam Sharma 44 Rana Maqbool 44 SLAPP statute 44 § #B#.# [002] 44 Justice PP Naolekar 44 construing statute 44 hereby AFFIRMED 44 Adv Simelane 44 Justice HL Dattu 44 adjudicates disputes 44 COTED 44 defendants appellees 44 collateral estoppel 44 Onyango Otieno 44 Boykin Tahl 44 caselaw 44 Grand Juries 44 judicature 44 impaneling 44 juridiction 44 Shariat Appellate Bench 44 disbarment proceedings 44 Judge Dinesh Dayal 44 predetermination 44 § #.# subd [002] 44 KK Tated 44 Justice AK Mathur 44 Lawrence Quintano 44 Fla. 3d DCA 44 controverted 44 C ounsel 44 Siegelman Scrushy 44 Justice Goundar 44 Justice Mohd Zaki 44 Judge Econg 44 plainly erred 44 UC Bannerjee 44 #B#.# 44 postconviction relief 44 Preliminary Enquiry 44 ICC Statute 44 Minn. R. Evid 44 Justice Mridula Bhatkar 44 Justice Manjula Chellur 44 movant 44 lawfully constituted 44 Coroners inquests 44 IC § #-# 44 nonstatutory 44 Dormant Commerce Clause 44 RCW #.#.# [004] 44 p laintiffs 44 Bishop Bennison 44 Judge Scheindlin 44 Justice Akanbi 44 Justice LS Panta 44 Mohd Diah 44 ref'd 44 NJSA #:#-# [004] 44 Magistrate Giovanni Grixti 44 mens rea 44 § #e 44 Leyla Sahin 44 posttrial motions 44 Appellants 44 Justice Kamocha 44 Sanjeev Jindal 44 particularize 44 Mark Hafle exercised 44 Justice Chinhengo 44 AEDPA 44 interlocutory application 44 Justice Kafarati 44 Ahmad Helmy Syed 44 Lawyer Disciplinary 44 Justice Nazhat Shameem 44 Justice KL Manjunath 44 judges Arijit Pasayat 44 inter parte 44 undue prejudice 44 Justice Gabriel Kolawole 44 Justice Adolfo Azcuna 44 counterclaims asserted 44 thirteenth juror 44 ECtHR 44 People v. Doganiere 44 Justice Emmanuel Amadi 44 Norman Arendse SC 44 KK Agha 44 lawyer Tracy Hembroff 44 NDCC ch 44 reasonable inferences therefrom 44 chairman Shivajirao Deshmukh 44 sixtieth session 44 Tennessee Code Annotated 44 nonconstitutional 44 mala fide intent 44 exculpation 44 Grievance Commission 44 Lord Mustill 44 writ petitioner 44 declaratory injunctive 44 Defendant Scrushy 44 section #-#-# [003] 44 Idaho Code § 44 Judge Ciparick 44 Justice Usha Mehra 44 magistrate Kafunda 44 Judge Zmuda 44 8 CFR § 44 Justice VK Tahilramani 44 articulable suspicion 44 judges Ruma Pal 44 plea colloquy 44 nonappealable 44 foreseeability 44 prejudice prong 44 Justice Dan Abutu 44 Lt. Col. Vandeveld 44 permissible inferences 44 qui tam relator 44 EACJ 44 subsection c 44 validly constituted 44 subsection h 44 Krishna Jung Rayamajhi 44 irrebuttable presumption 44 NCDRC 43 Rosenkrantz supra 43 obiter dictum 43 uncontroverted facts 43 Basmanny Court 43 § #.#.# [001] 43 ex parte 43 Justice Joseph Nyamu 43 Ark. R. Crim 43 Mr Rwakoojo 43 Mukta Gupta 43 recusal motion 43 § #-#-# [001] 43 Judge Bheki Maphalala 43 Turkel Commission 43 Antrix Devas deal 43 reh'g denied 43 collaterally attack 43 Damian Bugg 43 counsel KTS Tulsi 43 Burkert Brist 43 KRS #A.# [002] 43 UIFSA 43 justice MM Ruhul 43 Justice Tirath 43 OCGA § #-#-# [003] 43 g iven 43 unrebutted testimony 43 Judge Servaas 43 Justice Akinjide Ajakaiye 43 judge Yaakov Tirkel 43 Judge Muroski 43 OCGA § #-#-# [001] 43 Equitable tolling 43 Justice PV Kakade 43 Mr Akoto Ampaw 43 pretermitted 43 n.9 43 Justice Anup Raj 43 alleged contemnors 43 additur 43 nonsuit 43 Brisebill 43 PP Malhotra appearing 43 exculpatory clause 43 Andre Blignault 43 exparte motion 43 Justiciary 43 equitable estoppel 43 jurisdictional 43 Judge Anita Sukola 43 Rule #-# 43 duly constituted 43 Garda Ombudsman Commission 43 unpreserved 43 JNOV 43 congnisance 43 Katsina Alu 43 Section #-#-# [005] 43 Tsai Shou hsun 43 Ex parte Young 43 Kailash Gambhir 43 midtrial 43 unconscionability 43 Convening Authority 43 Justice Ouseley 43 PK Bhasin 43 pari delicto 43 NJSA 2A #A 43 Mohtasib 43 d efendants 43 indict Ozawa 43 e xcept 43 CFR § #.# [006] 43 Gopal Subramaniam appearing 43 sanctionable conduct 43 thecourt 43 restitutionary 43 Appellate Body 43 adducing 43 Justice Daniel Musinga 43 Justice Kuewumi 43 Olusola Oke 43 Justice Abhay Oka 43 Justice Binta Nyako 43 Pota Review 43 visitorial powers 43 res ipsa loquitur 43 Judge Stanley Sporkin 43 Judge Tatel 43 Justice Iftikhar Muhammed Chaudhry 43 Amended Complaint alleges 43 Anoop Mohta 43 En Banc 43 Justice Tijani Abubakar 43 Justices Joseph Nyamu 43 subsection d 43 Qatanani patently incomplete 43 Akil Mochtar 43 Gov't Br 43 delegable 43 El Hadji Malick Sow 43 improvidently granted 43 Magistrate Simusamba 43 Judge UD Salvi 43 conciliation mediation 43 Apablaza extradition 43 Dr Shahdeen Malik 43 allocution 43 § #-# [004] 43 Justice Veena Birbal 43 sufficient indicia 43 OCGA § #-#-# [008] 43 Sentelle wrote 43 Zafar Qureshi 43 Tahilyani 43 Plaintiff asserts 43 e ach 43 Min Bahadur Rayamajhi 43 BP Jeevan Reddy 43 Trustee Objection 43 USSG § #C#.# 43 mens rea element 43 prosecutor Rohini Salian 43 Abhay Thipsay 43 La. RS #:# [001] 43 Lord Eassie 43 Turkel Committee 43 severability provision 43 Coroner Azmil Muntapha Abas 43 Determinations Panel 43 Anti Injunction 43 AEDPA statute 43 #-# SDNY 43 FI Rebello 43 Justice Baragwanath 43 RC #.# [002] 43 intermediate appellate 43 Justice Regupathi 43 AND ADJUDGED 43 Judge Bruce Romanick 43 ACHPR 43 Apprendi v. New 43 Appellate Court 43 countervailable subsidy