Related by context. All words. (Click for frequent words.) 68 reasonable inferences drawn 66 credibility determinations 66 adduced 66 averments 62 adduce evidence 62 PW1 62 averment 61 reasonable inferences therefrom 61 uncharged misconduct 61 reasonable factfinder 60 probative value 60 uncontroverted facts 59 Defendant contends 59 prima facie case 59 appellant 59 factual determinations 58 petitioner 58 uncontradicted 58 nonmovant 58 Appellant contends 58 reasonable inferences 58 movant 58 factual sufficiency 58 uncontradicted testimony 58 c ourt 58 IJ adverse 58 prosecutrix 57 Appellant argues 57 ore tenus 57 uncontroverted testimony 57 reversible error 57 curative instruction 57 controverted 57 IJ erred 57 Defendant asserts 57 adduce 56 factual predicate 56 extrinsic evidence 56 Appellant asserts 56 magistrate Kafunda 56 Justice Oyewole 56 sua sponte duty 56 nonmoving party 56 Mohamad Zabidin 56 inferences therefrom 56 factfinder 56 prima facie 56 documentary evidences 56 procedural irregularity 56 plea colloquy 56 Petitioner 56 controvert 55 Spreigl evidence 55 Hlophe JP 55 Defendant argues 55 Justice Victor Omage 55 conclusory statements 55 malafides 55 hearsay objection 55 movants 55 UCBR 55 circumstantial evidences 55 procedurally defective 55 draw reasonable inferences 55 Faretta motion 55 reweigh 55 Ahamba 55 Justice Bhunu 55 Mohd Diah 55 appellants 55 procedurally barred 55 Roselyne Wendoh 55 factually distinguishable 55 mere scintilla 55 Justice Abban 55 corroborative evidence 55 rational factfinder 55 drawn therefrom 54 CALJIC No. #.# 54 unduly prejudicial 54 Nik Hashim 54 evidences 54 Ms Aikins 54 Justice Karwi 54 e vidence 54 Petitioner contends 54 WCJ 54 appellant asserts 54 factual inferences 54 magistrate Simusamba 54 Samuel Bosire 54 Justice Wowo 54 impugned judgment 54 particularized facts 54 BIA erred 54 evidentiary rulings 54 RCr #.# 54 Mrs Justice Abban 54 habeas proceeding 54 Zabidin Mohd Diah 54 Defendant Scrushy 54 triable 54 Lithur 54 prime facie 54 Their Lordships 54 procedural unconscionability 54 arguable merit 54 Justice Shameem 54 corpus delicti rule 53 caveatable interest 53 summarily affirm 53 contemporaneous objection 53 controverting evidence 53 Ibid. 53 Respondent contends 53 Justice Chinhengo 53 Justice Muga Apondi 53 adducing 53 Petitioner counsel 53 ALJ 53 habeas petitioner 53 Onyango Otieno 53 Appellants argue 53 reasonable trier 53 Izinyon 53 factual assertions 53 Justice Babs Kuewumi 53 corpus delicti 53 contemnors 53 Justice Farkye 53 factual contentions 53 Justice Mohamad Zabidin 53 establish prima facie 53 Movant 53 PW3 53 unanimity instruction 53 Justice Nazhat Shameem 53 JNOV motion 53 D efendant 52 joinder 52 Evidence Code 52 Justice Joseph Nyamu 52 Simeza 52 uncontroverted evidence 52 Justice Opene 52 Justice EK Ayebi 52 Justice Ogebe 52 Justice Mohd Zabidin 52 Waglay 52 Magistrate Jammeh 52 Appellant 52 parol evidence 52 Abodakpi 52 evidence preponderates 52 mala fides 52 acquital 52 justifiable inferences 52 appellant contends 52 JNOV 52 Mrs Georgina Mensah 52 ex parte application 52 Igbeke 52 CrR #.# 52 Justice Tijani Abubakar 52 postconviction 52 prima facie evidence 52 Judge Paddington Garwe 52 Justice Oguntade 52 contemnor 52 Judge Datuk Mohamad 52 admissible 52 acted ultra vires 52 plainly erred 52 perjurious testimony 52 Justice Akanbi 52 evidentiary objections 52 Justice Ofori Atta 52 affiant 52 Katutsi 52 Philip Waki 52 misapprehended 51 controverting 51 adduce sufficient 51 posttrial motions 51 advocate Wim Trengove 51 Justice Mohd Zaki 51 Justice Omerjee 51 Reply Brief 51 bsent 51 PW# [003] 51 La.Civ.Code art 51 colorable claim 51 factual underpinnings 51 Ozekhome 51 prejudice prong 51 NJRE 51 Magistrate Simusamba 51 Pitchess motion 51 remanding 51 ZHB 51 Namandje 51 instruct sua sponte 51 originating summons 51 Mr Mutembei 51 Justice Ayebi 51 Dr Mahtani 51 non justiciable 51 Mr. Narmont 51 habeas proceedings 51 writ petitioners 51 mootness 51 postconviction counsel 51 Justice Kamocha 51 adducing evidence 51 Adv Simelane 51 evidentiary 51 Justice Nyamu 51 Magistrate Mboto 51 Justice Gabriel Kolawole 51 Ian Farlam 51 postconviction petition 51 Plaintiff Complaint 51 procedural reasonableness 51 Presiding Magistrate 51 trier 51 Appellants contend 51 Abdull Hamid 51 presiding magistrate 51 enter nolle prosequi 51 entered nolle prosequi 51 McNicolls 51 deponent 51 Presidential Election Petitions 51 assessors Kate Choshi 51 voluntariness 51 Consuelo Scerri Herrera 51 CALCRIM No. 51 assuming arguendo 50 Justice Goundar 50 Justice Ade Alabi 50 rational trier 50 obiter dictum 50 sua sponte 50 justiciable 50 Election Petitions Tribunal 50 Iziyon 50 Justice Adamu Bello 50 Dr Khaminwa 50 Movants 50 Banjul Magistrate 50 Samateh 50 rebuttable 50 caselaw 50 p laintiff 50 liberally construe 50 Mr. Rotimi Jacobs 50 Appellants 50 Philip Tunoi 50 Fla. 2d DCA 50 Magistrate Sherman McNicolls 50 w hether 50 Judge Bosielo 50 substantively unreasonable 50 voire dire 50 nonfrivolous 50 alleged contemnor 50 postconviction motion 50 Election Petition Tribunal 50 uncharged misconduct evidence 50 mens rea 50 James Ogebe 50 substantive reasonableness 50 Makalo 50 plea allocution 50 uncontradicted evidence 50 Justice Garwe 50 establishes prima facie 50 Tibulya 50 Justice Ishaq Bello 50 ULJ 50 Judge GP Thareja 50 Justice Dhingra 50 EACJ 50 preponderate 50 4th DCA 50 Zabidin 50 Justice Daniel Musinga 50 affiants 50 originating summons filed 50 accusatory instrument 50 Evid. Code § 50 Daniel Aganyanya 50 Presidential Election Petition 50 inadmissible hearsay 50 i fa 50 ipse dixit 50 Magistrate Kafunda 50 Omage 50 Justice Pradeep Nandrajog 50 Principal Resident Magistrate 50 LHC Rawalpindi Bench 49 Kekere Ekun 49 Lateef Fagbemi SAN 49 unrebutted testimony 49 postjudgment motion 49 nolle 49 Judge Justice Nazhat 49 E vidence 49 Justice Adebukola Banjoko 49 Justice Daniel Goundar 49 REMANDED 49 Justice PK Bhasin 49 Justice VM Kanade 49 procedurally defaulted 49 counsel performed deficiently 49 refutable 49 PK Bhasin 49 POTA Review 49 probative 49 prima facia 49 Respondent concedes 49 Justice Surya Kant 49 judgment nunc pro 49 limine 49 pleadings 49 Kebba Sanyang 49 ACMM 49 Justice Anin Yeboah 49 excusable neglect 49 affirmance 49 d efendant 49 Justice Jamadar 49 Bwari Upper Area 49 Ibiyeye 49 Mr Chikumbirike 49 Justice Olubunmi Oyewole 49 Justice Sirpurkar 49 corroborative 49 bindover 49 Mumbuna 49 Eleventh Circuits 49 circumstancial evidence 49 Thomas Naron 49 Nchito 49 ref'd 49 P laintiffs 49 Markandeya Katju 49 parental unfitness 49 Ahmad Helmy Syed 49 Justice Kafarati 49 Opening Br 49 substantive unreasonableness 49 Justice Nanavati 49 evi dence 49 Mridula Bhatkar 49 Justice Tariq Parvez 49 Justice Venning 49 mootness doctrine 49 Kulendi 49 Adeniyi Akintola SAN 49 Mr. Olalekan Ojo 49 Pitchess discovery 49 Justice Kuewumi 49 Judge Ratha Mokgoatlheng 49 Justice Randerson 49 Justice Banjoko 49 Nkabinde J 49 interlocutory judgment 49 uncharged offenses 49 Justice Mufutau 49 Judge Willie Hartzenberg 49 Ararume 49 Kalejaye 49 Datuk Abdull Hamid Embong 49 summary judgment de novo 49 Justice Ibrahim Auta 49 untimeliness 49 Mc Nicolls 49 Hofsheier 49 respectfully submits 49 James Agalga 49 justiciable controversy 49 Judge SK Sarvaria 49 John Bosco Katutsi 49 Awa Kalu SAN 49 legally tenable 49 Daramani 49 u pon 49 preclude summary judgment 49 Prof Githu Muigai 49 Justice Baffoe Bonnie 49 Confrontation Clause 49 Justices Joseph Nyamu 49 nonobviousness 49 Kapoko 49 DPP Chenge 49 Rickey Tarfa SAN 49 Awodein 49 unduly prejudiced 49 exparte 49 Judge Bheki Maphalala 49 Justice Abutu 49 Babalola SAN 48 Justice Okon Abang 48 Justices GP Mathur 48 Justice Abdullahi Mustapha 48 judicial estoppel 48 declarants 48 Wochiunga 48 Kaphale 48 Tun Majid 48 Justice Garba Nabaruma 48 Nene Amegatcher 48 counsel Gobind Singh 48 ALJ erred 48 lawmaker Hosseini Sobhaninia 48 Wahab Shittu 48 CALCRIM Nos. 48 Muhammad Shafee 48 Justices SB Sinha 48 Justice Saka Ibiyeye 48 knowingly intelligently 48 Oyetibo 48 justiciability 48 Faretta 48 Younger abstention 48 Justice Tirath 48 procedurally unreasonable 48 Kamarul Hisham 48 Dr. Tunji Abayomi 48 Prosecuting Officer 48 propounder 48 Justice Samuel Bosire 48 Amua Sekyi 48 colorable 48 Justice Mohamad Ariff 48 Azmil Muntapha 48 nondischargeability 48 DP Wadhwa 48 dicta 48 PCRA hearings 48 criminal assizes 48 manifestly unsupported 48 PW2 48 judge Justice Nazhat 48 proximate causation 48 d efendants 48 Credibility determinations 48 comprising Justices P Sathasivam 48 Sandiganbayan justices 48 Oguntade 48 DPP Tun 48 Kasab confessional statement 48 Private Eric Modzaka 48 admissibility 48 Akiwumi 48 motion exparte 48 fi ndings 48 appellants contend 48 Election Petition 48 accused infringer 48 Agbaso 48 Balonwu 48 Lokeshwar Singh Panta 48 Respondent 48 Kwabena Acheampong 48 Olalekan Ojo 48 Manila RTC 48 Justice Apondi 48 Mongor 48 NWLR 48 Presentence Report 48 testimonial hearsay 48 Public Prosecution DPP 48 Dolsingh 48 Justice Maphalala 48 Justice Marful Sau 48 judge OP Saini 48 Lawyer Darboe 48 nontestimonial 48 Governorship Election 48 posttrial 48 Shivade 48 Justice Panckhurst 48 Kamarul Hisham Kamaruddin 48 Constance Byamugisha 48 incurably defective 48 Benjamin Kubo 48 exonerate Kapoor 48 duly constituted 48 requestor petitioner 48 mitigating circumstances 48 Justice Lawal Gummi 48 equitable estoppel 48 circumstantial evidence 48 Lionjanga 48 Assuming arguendo 48 claim preclusion 48 Justice Graham Panckhurst 48 Petitioner argues 48 Defendant 48 functus officio 48 Justice Chikere 48 Justice Duose 48 c ounsel 48 AR Lakshmanan 48 reh'g 48 Bulaya 48 competent evidential 48 construing statute 48 Justice Visram 48 Fadera 48 falsity 48 Zainal Abidin Kamarudin 48 Justice Ojwang 48 Wuaku Commission 48 Justice Cyriac Joseph 48 Stephen Adah 48 reasonably arguable 48 mistake inadvertence surprise 48 BIA denial 48 fraudulent joinder 48 compellable 48 Justice Udalagama 48 predicate acts 48 Biraogo 48 Justice Kpegah 48 conclusory allegations 48 Justice Kathryn Mickle 48 Kpl Sirul Azhar 47 Originating Summons 47 Justice Sandra Mungwira 47 Justice Katsina Alu 47 particularized 47 Mrs Kandara 47 Boykin Tahl 47 justices Arijit Pasayat 47 Bhangale 47 C ourt 47 res gestae 47 declarant 47 Zuma Thint 47 Justice Geoffrey Venning 47 Hanafiah Zakaria 47 additur 47 Justice Brobbey 47 sufficient indicia 47 nonfrivolous issue 47 raise triable 47 factually insufficient 47 Claimant contends 47 plead scienter 47 postjudgment 47 Judge ASJ 47 Basson acquittal 47 Justice Herbert Volney 47 Ayanlaja 47 arbitrability 47 evidential basis 47 Swatanter Kumar 47 Lord Bracadale 47 Justice TS Sivagnanam 47 JS Sidhu 47 senior advocate Mukul 47 Mr Bhila 47 collateral estoppel 47 Justice Abdul Kafarati 47 Nandlall 47 Asif Saeed Khosa 47 uncorroborated testimony 47 rule nisi 47 inculpatory 47 Uijs 47 reviewed de novo 47 5th DCA 47 intendment 47 Trustee Objection 47 Prosecution Witness 47 advocate Mukul Sinha 47 e ven 47 Ikpeazu 47 audi alteram partem 47 manifestly unreliable 47 Kafunda 47 u nless 47 Justice Ukeje 47 Datuk Abdul Kadir 47 Magistrate Moroka 47 Justice Festus Azangalala 47 conclusory 47 overbreadth 47 coram nobis 47 habeas relief 47 purely circumstantial 47 remittitur 47 Ngakaagae 47 JM Panchal 47 conclusory allegation 47 bifurcated proceeding 47 Roselyn Wendoh 47 Emmanuel O'Kubasu 47 Tsoka 47 Senator Abubakar Sodangi 47 exparte motion 47 Dr Bulaya 47 Judge Chinembiri Bhunu 47 vacatur 47 PK Balasubramanyam 47 Justice Sakala 47 Mathieu Ngudjolo Chui 47 evidence 47 allocution 47 adverse inference 47 Justice Whealy 47 admissability 47 Judge Waglay 47 Election Petitions 47 pleadings liberally 47 Justice HK Sema 47 Fagbohungbe 47 Justice Henrietta Abban 47 Nana Ato Dadzie 47 Borulkar 47 Oraro 47 Judge Rajender Kumar 47 Alex Iziyon SAN 47 reasonable inference 47 Otunba Fasawe 47 dispositive 47 Estrada plunder 47 Justice Hickinbottom 47 VACATE 47 Code § #-#.# 47 rendered nugatory 47 Max Labe 47 Magistrate Uanivi 47 Mr Bellanto 47 unrebutted evidence 47 Corporal Yaw Appiah 47 Mohammad Azizul Haque 47 Daniel Abutu 47 Mathebulas 47 Altantuya Shaariibuu murder 47 Judge BR Kedia 47 totally misconceived 47 Judge Vinod Kumar 47 Judge Mohamad Zabidin 47 Justice retd. 47 Judge Nordheimer 47 DDPP 47 Justice RS Mohite 47 demurrer 47 section #.#.# 47 hereby DISMISSED 47 Datsa 47 Collateral estoppel 47 unsworn 47 Justice Yaw Appau 47 form EC8A 47 Katsina Alu 47 La. Code Civ 47 thirteenth juror 47 Philip Murgor 47 estoppel 47 Justice CK Thakkar 47 Justice Usha Mehra 47 conclusory assertion 47 Uchena 47 Justice Dan Abutu 47 Sithambaram 47 preponderance 47 SL Bhayana 47 People v. Gardeley 47 lawyer Roel Pulido 47 deportability 47 Md Yasin 47 Sirul Azhar 47 Justice Maruping Dibotelo 47 Justice Mungwira 47 Adjei Frimpong 47 validly constituted 47 Mr Kilach 47 Mohammed Liman 47 Claimant argues 47 Justices CK Thakker 47 BS Joon 47 NWLR Pt. 47 ponencia 47 Justice KK Sasidharan 46 verdict acquitting 46 manifestly unreasonable 46 defendant 46 complainant 46 Justice Lambo Akanbi 46 Leonard Njagi 46 posttrial motion 46 counsel KTS Tulsi 46 respondent 46 Justice Egbo Egbo 46 Tribunal CSRT 46 habeas corpus proceeding 46 precluded summary judgment 46 Section #.#.# [001] 46 Rohtagi appearing 46 Devinadera 46 Justices KS Radhakrishnan 46 pleader 46 lawyer Kioko Kilukumi 46 Mokgoatlheng 46 Ms Justice Laffoy 46 Palmolein case 46 Judge Tahaliyani 46 aggravating circumstances 46 Tanenglian 46 Justices RV Raveendran 46 dispositive motion 46 Erastus Githinji 46 Rooker Feldman doctrine 46 Magistrate Edwina Grima 46 court prejudicially erred 46 La.Code Crim.P. art 46 undue prejudice 46 affidavits depositions 46 Justice Manmohan Sarin 46 Byabakama 46 improvidently granted 46 Harjit Singh Bedi 46 Rule #:#-# [001] 46 Lord Glennie 46 Justice Hamma Barka 46 Ndoma Egba 46 Kwame Akuffo 46 Justice Lakshmanan 46 Agabi 46 procedurally flawed 46 factfinding 46 George Oguntade 46 Justice Mudgal 46 granting anticipatory bail 46 Ginwala Enquiry 46 Judge Joop Labuschagne 46 counsel Mukul Sinha 46 Judge Sprizzo 46 Dibotelo 46 Limine 46 Justice Umar Ata 46 Justice Cowdroy 46 Rule #:#-# [002] 46 THIS CAUSE 46 Justice Salesi Temo 46 Judge Hilary Squires 46 Justice Levers 46 Bulama 46 Neil Tuchten 46 Tarun Chatterjee 46 Dr Mohd Razali 46 Olusola Oke 46 Justice Chidyausiku 46 Justice Monageng 46 issue preclusion 46 circumstantial evidence linking 46 Roshan Dalvi 46 AM Thipsay 46 evidential 46 inter parte 46 Judge SM Komathy 46 Ricky Tarfa SAN 46 Justice Nye Perram 46 Judge Kode 46 summary judgment motion 46 Justices Aftab Alam 46 Magistrate Consuelo Scerri Herrera 46 Justice RS Sodhi 46 Abe Motala 46 propria persona 46 Cuno Tarfusser 46 argument unpersuasive 46 Construing 46 Justice Ayo Salami 46 advocate Johann Engelbrecht 46 Dr Kuria 46 Judge Benotto 46 mandamus petition 46 P Sathasivam 46 preclusion 46 hearsay testimony 46 Navera 46 Justice DM Dharmadhikari 46 Justice Akinjide Ajakaiye 46 mandamus proceeding 46 Anuradhapura Magistrate 46 ECZ chairperson 46 Judge Anton Veldhuizen 46 blameworthiness 46 wholly unsupported 46 Gyan Sudha Misra 46 Fryo 46 interlocutory 46 Magistrate Buba Jawo 46 Bandial 46 amicus curaie 46 CPIO 46 B Sudershan Reddy 46 Delehey 46 Judge Lee Bozalek 46 causation 46 OCGA § #-#-# [007] 46 relator 46 Ms Syme 46 Kiplenge 46 Adversary Proceeding 46 lenity 46 Justice Remmy Kasule 46 Aturu 46 Tsikata 46 IJ denial 46 Manjeet Singh Dhillon 46 w hen 46 HK Sema 46 Justices RS Sodhi 46 factual 46 Justice Dzamefe 46 Chief TA Orji 46 postconviction relief 46 Justice Nasirul Mulk 46 materiality 46 pled nolo contendere 46 Compl. ¶ 46 Emmanuel Fagbenle 46 Tahaliyani 46 inapposite 46 Mr Justice Flaux 46 testimony 46 Justice MY Eqbal 46 Justice Lawrence Kamocha 46 Justices Shiranee 46 Dalhatu 46 NDPP 46 writ petitioner 46 JLSC 46 Justice Salisu Garba 46 Ombeta 46 AND ADJUDGED 46 corroborating evidence 46 mitigating circumstance 46 Chief Magistrate Aggrey 46 lawyer Amin Solkar 46 Bernard Kalove 46 hereby DENIED 46 Judicature Act 45 antenuptial agreement 45 Phillip Levinsohn 45 Justice Peter Dutney 45 attained finality 45 Rwakoojo 45 crossexamination 45 indefiniteness 45 lawyer Devanesh Sharma 45 grievant 45 chief magistrate Aggrey 45 Dr Pornthip 45 John Osiemo 45 Minn. Stat 45 mens rea requirement 45 cognizable 45 uncontroverted 45 Justices Tarun Chatterjee 45 Justice Giannino Caruana 45 justices P Sathasivam 45 pari materia 45 Iivula Ithana 45 Justice Kuldip Singh 45 Kafarati 45 procedural unfairness 45 CALCRIM 45 convict Spector 45 Perak mentri besar 45 Assistant Appellate Defender 45 Jafta AJ 45 Concourt judges 45 Adv Bizos 45 Justice Hungwe 45 Judge IK Kochhar 45 overborne 45 IT IS ORDERED 45 quasi judicial proceeding 45 plainly erroneous 45 His Lordship 45 Sofunde 45 fortiori 45 Cezar Mancao 45 granting summary judgment 45 genocidal intent 45 v. Mukasey 45 Jones Dotse 45 malafide intention 45 Justice Binta Murtala Nyako 45 lawyer Sisa Namandje 45 Ensa Badjie 45 Fed.R.Civ.P. 45 Justice Roseline Ukeje 45 preclusive effect 45 Justice NK Jain 45 Javed Buttar 45 testimonies 45 presumptively prejudicial 45 Justice Luka Kimaru 45 Id. 45 Justice Kornreich 45 Oputa Panel 45 CJM Srinagar 45 Circumstantial evidence 45 requisite mens rea 45 Elias Zacarias 45 § 7A 45 Reinholtsen 45 qazaf 45 demurrers 45 specific articulable facts 45 lawyer Ejaz Naqvi 45 Statutory Declaration 45 Mr Kafunda 45 claimant 45 Mike Ahamba SAN 45 Inquiry COI 45 Brian Collis QC 45 Piet Streicher 45 surely unattributable 45 Gen. Stat 45 Judge Ewaschuk 45 unsworn testimony 45 Manewe 45 Lorredo 45 interlocutory application 45 Reyat perjury trial 45 Justice Emmanuel Amadi 45 NCDRC 45 Election Tribunals 45 Andrew Somawansa 45 beyond peradventure 45 Mr Owayo 45 Albishir 45 Judge Econg 45 Judge Dinesh Dayal 45 § #-#.# [002] 45 Judge Sisi Khampepe 45 discountenanced 45 CESTAT 45 judge Abhay Thipsay 45 Justice PP Naolekar 45 Justice Mushir Alam 45 Mboge 45 obiter 45 judge Hamaundu 45 Philip Musonda 45 ruled inadmissable 45 dispositional hearing 45 Prosecuting counsel 45 VS Sirpurkar 45 objectively verifiable 45 Tikka Iqbal 45 manifestly erroneous 45 Kasab confession 45 postconviction proceeding 45 magistrate Lawrence Quintano 45 nonsuit 45 JMOL 45 Tony Lithur 45 Lawyer Mboge 45 Chinhengo 45 Justice Jitendra Chauhan 45 § 7B 45 judges Arijit Pasayat 45 ole Keiwua 45 Judge Chiman Patel 45 jurisdictional defect 45 prosecutor Zaais van Zyl 45 Magistrate Saviour Demicoli 45 Minn. R. Evid 45 totality 45 CHRAJ 45 Tun Abdul Majid 45 foreseeability 45 Joseph Nyamu 45 determinations de novo 45 sua sponte dismissal 45 spokesman Renato Bocar 45 dism'd 45 OCGA § #-#-# [008] 45 assertedly 45 Regeru 45 Justice Waki 45 unexhausted claims 45 counterclaims asserted 45 appelate 45 locus standi 45 SB Sinha 45 inapplicability 45 Judge Louis Bidois