Related by context. All words. (Click for frequent words.) 59 Legal Counsel OLC 58 Yoo Bybee 57 Legal Counsel 54 torture memos 52 Counsel Alberto Gonzales 52 DOJ OLC 52 Torture Memo 52 Bybee Yoo 51 Bybee Memo 51 Jay Bybee 50 OLC opinions 49 OLC memos 48 Dawn Johnsen 48 OLC memo 48 Bybee 47 coercive interrogation techniques 47 enhanced interrogation techniques 47 Yoo Jay Bybee 47 waterboarding 47 EITs 47 memos justifying 47 DOJ OPR 46 interrogation methods 46 CIA interrogators 46 AUMF 46 Bybee memo 45 interrogation techniques 45 Torture Memos 45 nominee Dawn Johnsen 45 DNI 45 CIA interrogation 45 coercive interrogations 45 coercive interrogation 45 Waterboarding 45 SERE instructors 45 Yoo 45 S. Bybee 45 harsh interrogation techniques 45 waterboard 44 counsel Alberto Gonzales 44 justifying harsh interrogation 44 Rasul v. Bush 44 JUSTICE STEVENS 43 interrogation technique 43 Detainee Treatment Act 43 JAGs 43 CIA harsh interrogation 43 Professional Responsibility 43 authorize warrantless wiretapping 43 warrantless surveillance program 43 Enhanced Interrogation Techniques 43 Harold Koh 43 Mukasey 43 warrantless surveillance 42 Boumediene v. Bush 42 Ashcroft 42 Neal Katyal 42 Gorelick memo 42 Philip Zelikow 42 aggressive interrogation techniques 42 harshest interrogation techniques 42 Legal Counsel memos 42 NSA surveillance 42 Branzburg 42 TTIC 42 Zelikow 42 Johnson v. Eisentrager 42 Marty Lederman 42 harsh interrogation 42 Terrorist Surveillance Program 42 Jamie Gorelick 41 SCOTUS 41 Laurence Tribe 41 Edwin Kneedler 41 Hamdi v. 41 memos authorizing 41 Executive Privilege 41 ISOO 41 Golove 41 NSA warrantless surveillance 41 GTMO 41 Ms. Gorelick 41 Gregory Garre 41 Rehnquist 41 RFRA 41 habeas stripping 41 waterboarding technique 41 Guantánamo 41 Unitary Executive 41 NSA spying 41 SERE 41 slaps freezing temperatures 41 Judge Alito 41 Special Counsel 41 antitorture laws 41 Marc Thiessen 41 NSA wiretapping 41 enemy combatants 41 Bradford Berenson 41 NIEs 41 harsh interrogation tactics 41 Justice Scalia 41 Brian A. Benczkowski 40 Valerie Caproni 40 sub silentio 40 legal memos justifying 40 CIA interrogations 40 Hamdan v. 40 Miers 40 warrantless wiretap program 40 Gonzales v. Carhart 40 Geneva Conventions 40 coercive interrogation tactics 40 harsher interrogation techniques 40 Judge Bork 40 Appointments Clause 40 simulated drownings known 40 MSPB 40 detainee interrogation 40 Alberto Gonzales 40 condones torture 40 Judge Tatel 40 antitorture 40 Military Commissions Act 40 interrogation tactics 40 memos detailing 40 Monica Goodling 40 von Spakovsky 40 infamous Dred Scott 40 memos 40 Freeh 40 Justice Harry Blackmun 40 DOJ 40 IRTPA 39 prosecute CIA interrogators 39 interrogation memos 39 loyal Bushies 39 interrogations 39 Justice Breyer 39 FLRA 39 SIGAR 39 Guantánamo detainee 39 Doctrine 39 SERE techniques 39 abusive interrogation techniques 39 Professional Responsibility OPR 39 State Secrets Privilege 39 TOTENBERG 39 Viet Dinh 39 EOUSA 39 Marbury v. 39 CFPB 39 stare decisis 39 Justices Breyer 39 FISA 39 Enhanced Interrogation 39 attorney Amrit Singh 39 Yoo memos 39 warrantless wiretaps 39 harsh interrogation methods 39 CIAs 39 Gonzales perjured himself 39 Rachel Meeropol 39 Judge Johnnie Rawlinson 39 OPR 39 PLRA 39 Guantánamo Bay 39 reasonably arguable 39 AEDPA 39 Katsas 39 Flast 39 Ms. Miers 39 unlawful combatants 39 Moral Reasoning 39 Ms. Goodling 39 Janet Reno 38 coercive interrogation methods 38 Jonathan Fredman 38 Dissenting Opinion 38 Bolschwing 38 Justice Rehnquist 38 defend DOMA 38 George Tenent 38 NSA warrantless wiretapping 38 Gilbert Nares 38 coercive techniques 38 OIG 38 reexamination proceeding 38 Tatel 38 Tribunal CSRT 38 interjurisdictional immunity 38 Lithwick 38 solicitor general 38 William Rehnquist 38 Norm Eisen 38 Robb Silberman 38 Geneva conventions 38 Interrogation techniques 38 catastrophically corrosive Faddis 38 Judge Steeh 38 Geneva Conventions protections 38 warrantless wiretapping 38 Military Tribunals 38 CIA counterterrorist 38 recess appointment 38 warrantless eavesdropping 38 § #.# [002] 38 manifest disregard 38 Harold Hongju Koh 38 Mukasey nomination 38 warrantless domestic 38 Stephen MacNett 38 originalism 38 Fred Fielding 38 warrantless wiretapping program 38 al Odah v. 38 Rove 38 § #-#.# [004] 38 v. Raich 38 Guantánamo detainees 38 NSLs 38 CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS 38 construing statutes 38 UIGEA 38 Gitmo 38 waterboarding repugnant 38 NSA warrantless eavesdropping 38 Abe Fortas 38 Yalof 38 Guantanamo 38 claim preclusion 38 JUSTICE BREYER 38 declassified memos 38 Steven Bradbury 38 OIRA 38 Military Commissions 38 Alito 38 Meralco GSIS case 38 Solomon Amendment 38 BPAI 38 Douglas Kmiec 38 Ninth Circuit 38 CIA 38 Jeffrey Minear 37 Stansfield Turner 37 Tafas v. Doll 37 Lord Goldsmith 37 diGenova 37 Hans Corell 37 PAJA 37 harsh interrogations 37 Karl Rove Harriet Miers 37 adjudicative functions 37 Harriet Miers 37 mootness 37 shall construe 37 Louis Briskman 37 OLC memoranda 37 JPRA 37 AB Buzzy Krongard 37 OCGA § #-#-# [007] 37 CSRTs 37 originalist interpretation 37 Convention Against Torture 37 Counterterrorist Center 37 JSOC 37 John Ashcroft 37 detaining enemy combatants 37 simulated drowning technique 37 Justices Scalia Thomas 37 Victoria Toensing 37 Brett Kavanaugh 37 FSIA 37 Judge Dyk 37 Shannen Coffin 37 J. Fred Buzhardt 37 Blackmun 37 FSIO 37 condone torture 37 Solicitor General Kagan 37 Timothy Flanigan 37 judicial estoppel 37 Rita Garman 37 revealing Plame identity 37 Act RFRA 37 Powers Resolution 37 Tjoflat 37 originalist 37 GITMO 37 SCR #:#.# [001] 37 Tenth Circuit 37 Ex parte Young 37 Helen E. Hoens 37 Stephen G. Breyer 37 Habeus Corpus 37 adjudicatory 37 RLUIPA 37 Meisburg 36 Brad Berenson 36 adjudicative 36 enemy combatant classification 36 Wermiel 36 Monica Goodling Gonzales 36 abusive interrogations 36 Louis Freeh 36 JUSTICE SCALIA 36 respectfully dissent 36 USC § #b [002] 36 judicially enforceable 36 Gonzales 36 Katyal 36 OAH 36 Legislative Counsel 36 faithfully execute 36 Rooker Feldman doctrine 36 FCC untrammeled 36 Patriot Act 36 PDBs 36 Declaratory Judgment Act 36 NDPP 36 Shayana Kadidal 36 unreviewable 36 detain enemy combatants 36 Alito dissented 36 George Tenet 36 Judge Cabranes 36 torture 36 SIGIR 36 parol evidence 36 Congressionally 36 Daniel Dell'Orto 36 Roe v. Wade 36 Lewis Scooter Libby 36 Guantanamo Bay 36 quasi judicial proceeding 36 Confrontation Clause 36 concurring opinions 36 Evid 36 interrogating prisoners 36 Aurene Martin 36 MoCRI 36 Polsby 36 Younger abstention 36 exclusionary rule 36 Adam Liptak 36 Obscenity Prosecution Task Force 36 Carlson Thies 36 DoJ 36 Antonin Scalia dissented 36 Professor Chemerinsky 36 CSRT 36 IIRIRA 36 Frederick Fleitz 36 Hans von Spakovsky 36 Tom Malinowski 36 Comey 36 Linda Copple Trout 36 peremptory writ 36 Corporate Counsel OGCC 36 waterboard constitutes 36 EACJ 36 Geneva Conventions quaint 36 professor Dawn Johnsen 36 Sekulow 36 Holder 36 Judge Ciparick 36 Justices Sonia Sotomayor 36 renditions Lena 36 Judge Sotomayor 36 doctrine 36 Doug Kmiec 36 enemy combatants classification 36 waterboarding sleep deprivation 36 Don Icsman 36 Geneva Convention 36 appointor 36 SecDef 36 Judge Consuelo Callahan 36 PFIAB 36 NSL statutes 36 NSA eavesdropping 36 First Amendment jurisprudence 36 Nuclear Posture Review 36 Philip Heymann 36 Feith 36 interrogating detainees 36 concurring opinion Justice Antonin 36 Defendant argues 36 John Radsan 36 Edwin Meese III 36 approving harsh interrogation 36 attorney Rachel Meeropol 36 FOIA 36 Frederick Hitz 36 memoranda 36 warrantless electronic 36 pari materia 36 JTF GTMO 36 Strossen 35 MUKASEY 35 Zackery Morazzini 35 Dickey Wicker Amendment 35 NSPD 35 OMB 35 Judge Gertner 35 lawyers Jay Bybee 35 CrR #.# 35 Odaini 35 v. Gore 35 Enemy Combatants 35 Spakovsky 35 KSM 35 OFBCI 35 habeas 35 Judge Kollar Kotelly 35 Shayana Kadidal lawyer 35 Elana Wills 35 Guantanamo tribunals 35 Radsan 35 Acquisition Advisory Panel 35 Regarding Weapons 35 habeas petitioners 35 waterboarding simulated drowning 35 warrantless spying 35 Hina Shamsi 35 ACLU 35 DOMA 35 Barbara Olshansky 35 declassify memos 35 UCBR 35 UNCAT 35 Justice William Rehnquist 35 Petitioner asserts 35 Sloviter 35 Solicitor General 35 authorize warrantless wiretaps 35 HRS § #-# [001] 35 Buzzy Krongard 35 ALBERTO GONZALES 35 Austell Ga. Blake 35 OSTP 35 Judge Tauro 35 appellate 35 Quo Warranto 35 exigent letters 35 MEJA 35 Francis X. Flaherty 35 Geneva Accords 35 DLSE 35 Death Penalty Moratorium Implementation 35 Guantnamo 35 recess appointments 35 Berghuis v. Thompkins 35 Sibel Edmonds 35 Tribunals 35 visitorial powers 35 Sec Def 35 Bin Laden Determined 35 lawyer Neal Katyal 35 loyal Bushie 35 Judge Robert Bork 35 Jury nullification 35 Director Stansfield Turner 35 SecDef Gates 35 CIA Counterterrorist Center 35 Acting Solicitor General 35 Michael Dreeben 35 William Leaphart 35 Burkert Brist 35 Elizabeth Rindskopf Parker 35 Bader Ginsburg 35 PATRIOT Act 35 Petitioners contend 35 FISC 35 Von Spakovsky 35 equitable subordination 35 Intelligence Authorization 35 administration 35 First Ammendment 35 COICA 35 Alberto Roldan 35 Dickey Wicker amendment 35 Schlozman 35 warrantless wiretap 35 NSA 35 Rooker Feldman 35 Double Jeopardy Clause 35 SPECTER 35 caselaw 35 conservative jurists 35 Harsh interrogations 35 authorizing harsh interrogation 35 OCIO 35 Wesley Pruden 35 Legal Adviser 35 OGAC 35 Faretta 35 Luttig 35 NSDD 35 detainees 35 Judge Ambro 35 textualist 35 Scooter Libby 35 prosecutive 35 Kagan 35 Carl Artman 35 Counsel Fred Fielding 35 PFAWF 35 issue preclusion 35 CIA briefer 35 originalists 34 Benjamin Civiletti 34 WINPAC 34 v. Cronic 34 Robb Silberman Commission 34 Wartime Contracting Commission 34 USA Patriot Act 34 lawyer Anthony Coppolino 34 constitutionally prescribed 34 decisional 34 Torture 34 cruel inhumane 34 Grutter v. Bollinger 34 Presidential Directive 34 UCMJ 34 Eighth Amendment 34 Judge Anthony Scirica 34 Deborah T. Poritz 34 Guantanomo 34 Tom Josefiak 34 Dale Sandstrom 34 Congressman Conyers 34 Aziz Huq 34 Issue preclusion 34 Peter T. Zarella 34 National Intelligence DNI 34 McNulty Memo 34 Zubaydah interrogation 34 Zubaydah 34 Valerie Plame affair 34 Steve MacNett 34 Gitmo detainees 34 Robert Hildum 34 EESA 34 Mirandized 34 habeas petitioner 34 Johns Gorvy 34 judicial nominations 34 overrule Roe 34 Eighth Amendments 34 Humanist Manifesto 34 Beth Brinkmann 34 preemption doctrine 34 Movants 34 interlocutory appeals 34 unreviewable discretion 34 Justices Scalia 34 interrogation 34 Justice Abe Fortas 34 Code § #-# [003] 34 Justice Felix Frankfurter 34 jus ad bellum 34 FDNS 34 Free Exercise Clause 34 FLPMA 34 Counterintelligence Field Activity 34 Ben Veniste 34 Ms. Dannehy 34 Toensing 34 Grizzle FAA 34 ponencia 34 Counterproliferation Division 34 Bilski v. Kappos 34 guru Karl Rove 34 suspend habeas corpus 34 MaxHR 34 Torture Statute 34 equitably tolled 34 Administrative Procedures Act 34 Jameel Jaffer ACLU 34 indefinite detention 34 Joseph Margulies 34 FAR #.#-# [002] 34 Rule #-#.# 34 Kmiec 34 Enemy combatants 34 Justices Thurgood Marshall 34 foreclose litigant success 34 Combatant Status Review Tribunals 34 SERE psychologists 34 aide Monica Goodling 34 NIE 34 Wickard v. Filburn 34 Felix Frankfurter 34 interpreting statutes 34 Congressman Porter Goss 34 Ms. Baskins 34 Joint Unconventional Warfare 34 concurring opinion Justice 34 Sri Srinivasan 34 Field Manual 34 Lamberth 34 HUMINT 34 habeas proceeding 34 outlaw waterboarding 34 Lt. Col. Vandeveld 34 sharply worded dissent 34 PCAOB 34 Rehnquist dissented 34 pre decisional 34 Pentagon Papers 34 Yugoslav tribunal 34 Appellants argue 34 Bruselas 34 NSA warrantless spying 34 Petitioner argues 34 imperial presidency 34 per curiam 34 Aplt 34 Field Manual #-#.# 34 Carol Ronning Kapsner 34 General Alberto Gonzales 34 Justice William Leaphart 34 Les Kondo 34 O'Scannlain 34 reargued 34 Emmanuel Fagbenle 34 NSL statute 34 John K. Konenkamp 34 nominating Harriet Miers 34 § #-#-# [006] 34 SCALIA 34 JUSTICE GINSBURG 34 detailees 34 Miers nomination 34 mootness doctrine 34 Task Force Execute 34 Clerked 34 Bernard Nussbaum 34 Gitmo prisoners 34 Zadvydas 34 detainable 34 dormant Commerce Clause 34 Zbigniew Wasserman 34 CYBERCOM 34 Great Writ 34 Goodling 34 unlawful enemy combatants 34 Cyber Czar 34 namo Bay 34 Charles Cully Stimson 34 Guantanamo prisoners 34 Feres doctrine 34 Elisa Massimino 34 William H. Rehnquist 34 BAPCPA 34 Attorney Client Privilege 34 el Masri rendition 34 ATCSA 34 scholar Cass Sunstein 34 CFR § #.# [005] 34 Security Presidential Directive 34 prosecute leakers 34 subsection c 34 Zansberg 34 Justice Reynato Puno 34 Sotomayor dissented 34 Renato Corona 34 Stenberg v. Carhart 34 Gimigliano 34 HCJ 34 Joint Interrogation 34 Bork 34 Appeared unsure 33 Jeffrey Breinholt 33 Heidi Boghosian 33 FOI Act 33 regulating interstate commerce 33 waterboarded 33 PHILIPPE SANDS 33 Guantanamo Bay detention 33 Article XIX 33 Al Odah v. 33 penal substitution 33 AND WHEREAS 33 Debate Clause 33 Carla Stovall 33 military tribunals 33 Totenberg 33 Guantánamo captives 33 extraconstitutional 33 jus cogens 33 authorized CIA interrogators 33 unenumerated rights 33 Ex parte Quirin 33 Res judicata 33 Kocoras 33 Rogowskyj 33 Nuremberg Principles 33 W. Kmiec 33 Jami Miscik 33 Cass Sunstein 33 constituional 33 Judicially 33 Guant 33 Adam Ciongoli 33 NSA wiretaps 33 Exclusionary Rule 33 SERE training 33 Harry Blackmun 33 mentioned AB Culvahouse 33 Plame leak 33 Ifdhal 33 parol evidence rule 33 Framers 33 Pelander 33 Ginsburg Breyer 33 SLUSA 33 Suspension Clause 33 Pamela Karlan 33 WHIG 33 NDCC ch 33 SECDEF 33 Decision Directive 33 Rule #:#-# [002] 33 Brian Benczkowski 33 Remedios Salazar Fernando 33 Jae Whan JW 33 Constitution framers 33 isolation sensory deprivation 33 Pildes 33 Miranda warnings 33 al Qida 33 Counterintelligence Field Activity CIFA 33 CMUs 33 condoning torture 33 RCW #.#A.# 33 super duper precedent 33 judicial nominees 33 Federalist Society 33 OPCAT 33 enemy combatants indefinitely 33 Branzburg v. Hayes 33 declassified summary 33 dissenting justices 33 Warrantless Wiretaps 33 Wheelbarger 33 Verrilli 33 CIA operatives 33 Slaughterhouse Cases 33 Ex Parte Milligan 33 Non Interventionist 33 separate concurring opinion 33 § #-#-# [003] 33 Cheney 33 Justice Dante Tinga 33 habeas statute 33 Judge Scheindlin 33 committed impeachable offenses 33 enemy combatant 33 Skadden Arps Meagher 33 Guantanamos 33 Justice Helen Hoens 33 movants 33 Presidential Oath 33 unallotment statute 33 Perino lavished praise 33 Theo van Boven 33 narrowly circumscribed 33 secrets privilege 33 unlawful combatant 33 By Gale Courey 33 Pam Karlan 33 Wittes 33 detainee interrogations 33 Originalism 33 CACI interrogators 33 Justices Ginsburg 33 Antitrust Modernization Commission 33 Sunstein 33 NSA Wiretapping 33 Ed Meese 33 arbitrability 33 Scalia 33 detainee Abu Zubaydah 33 BTWC 33 NSA warrantless wiretaps 33 KRS #A.# [001] 33 mastermind Khalid Sheik Mohammed 33 Kemp Kasten 33 pardon Scooter Libby 33 Miller Fienen 33 interrogators 33 Joel Obar 33 waterboarding harsh interrogation 33 Mukasey confirmation hearings 33 Constitution 33 National Intelligence ODNI 33 5th DCA 33 Peter Wehner 33 Director RT Harbo 33 affirmance 33 BIA 33 Chas Freeman 33 vacatur 33 Laches 33 Borry Touray 33 Guantanamo detainees 33 Keisler oversaw 33 attorney Ben Wizner 33 Wilmer Hale 33 nominative fair 33 USCCR 33 Skadden Fellowship 33 Dahlia Lithwick 33 CFR § #.# [004] 33 USIA 33 Insurrection Act 33 Fortas 33 spokeswoman Nicole Guillemard 33 Eddie Speas 33 Jennifer Daskal 33 Dusty Foggo 33 William Renquist 33 Daryl Joseffer 33 Mark Tushnet 33 Judge Diarmuid F. 33 5TH CIR 33 Due Process Clause 33 Sidley Austin 33 Legal Practitioners Act 33 b ecause 33 Boumediene 33 Judicature Act 33 Dell'Orto 33 Equitable tolling 33 Martha Minow 33 simulates drowning 33 precedential 33 Laurie Zelon 33 counselor Harriet Miers 33 confirmation hearings 33 Lichtblau 33 Legal Draftsman 33 Samuel Alito dissented 33 Guantanamo Bay Cuba 33 Phillip Jauregui 33 JLSC 33 ARS § #-#.# 33 Dr Mataim Bakar 33 Pailca 33 Douglas Kmiec Pepperdine 33 degrading treatment 33 ENRD 33 Defendant asserts 33 Judge JL Edmondson 33 Silberman Robb Commission 33 Caitlin Halligan 33 Intelligence Agency 33 factfinding 33 Intelligence Committees 33 comitology procedure 33 Creppy 33 Shakman Decree 33 Hertling emphatically stated 33 Darius Charney 33 BEN VENISTE 33 spokesman Mark Corallo 33 Originalist 33 CFR § #.# [007] 33 Shesol 33 Cabranes 33 Interior DOI 33 Flag Desecration Amendment 33 Cardinal Ratzinger 33 NCCUSL 33 CONPLAN 33 Chris Oprison 33 Mastermind Confesses 33 HJ Res 33 hooding prisoners 33 Judge Muroski 33 factual determinations 33 Judge Preska 33 Stephen Tuber 33 Ninth Circuits 32 Mirandize 32 Justices Souter 32 Justice Joette Katz 32 Miers Bolten 32 David Aufhauser 32 High Value Detainee 32 OIPRD 32 clerkships 32 Sovereign Immunity 32 Wengi 32 Seventh Circuits 32 Siac 32 Nuremburg trials 32 concurrences 32 Greg Petesch 32 Scotusblog.com 32 Riegel v. 32 counterterrorism counterintelligence 32 Timothy Mayopoulos 32 memos outlining 32 Philip Schiliro 32 Indefinite Detention 32 habeas proceedings 32 ICTR 32 lawful combatants 32 suspected terrorists 32 Goals Objectives 32 Wilmer Cutler Pickering 32 ISDA Master Agreement 32 EFF 32 textualism 32 § #C#.# 32 Wesberry v. Sanders 32 slapping simulated drowning 32 Judicial Selection Commission 32 PS § 32 Dr Shahdeen Malik 32 Escape SERE 32 Nashiri 32 Joseph diGenova 32 Karl Rove 32 wise Latina remark 32 Fourth Amendment 32 Twelfth Amendment 32 USA PATRIOT 32 Falah al Hajeri 32 ex turpi causa 32 Pre emptive pardons 32 Ted Ullyot 32 OCCA 32 Interrogation Methods 32 P laintiff 32 FOIA requesters 32 construed liberally 32 extrajudicial 32 judicial usurpation 32 Ashcroft recusal 32 Convening Authority 32 Fifth Amendments 32 HPSCI 32 Meese 32 Hartmann supervises 32 Survive Evade Resist 32 constitutional prerogatives 32 Judge Abner Mikva 32 Regime Crimes Liaison 32 Caroline Frederickson 32 Judge Laurence Silberman 32 Judge Kermit Lipez 32 CEQA Guidelines 32 Handschu guidelines 32 Alberto R. 32 Speechwriting 32 J. Cofer Black 32 Foreign Intelligence Surveillance 32 Colorado Revised Statutes 32 summary affirmance 32 Jan Witold Baran 32 counterproliferation division 32 Justice Rosalie Abella 32 Evan Gicheru 32 Staff Joshua Bolten 32 Marine Corps Counterinsurgency 32 CFR § #.# [001] 32 Sandra Ikuta 32 Patience Drake Roggensack 32 overbreadth doctrine 32 Sasa Vukadinovic 32 Phil Tydingco 32 Posse Comitatus Act 32 Otto Reich 32 Melendez Diaz 32 Ambassador Davidow 32 Qahtani 32 Bork hearings 32 Zubayda 32 Securing Cyberspace 32 KUBARK 32 Bushie 32 Libby 32 ad hoc tribunals 32 Robert Bork 32 Marcy Wheeler 32 OFPP 32 Henri Alleg 32 purposive interpretation 32 Martha B. Sosman 32 p rior 32 Joseph Kanefield 32 Mchenga 32 relitigation 32 Judicial Nominees 32 relator